Home 9 Immigration 9 Third-country nationals -Long-term resident status- concept of “resources”

Third-country nationals -Long-term resident status- concept of “resources”

by | Nov 9, 2021 10:28

Image: unsplash.com

In X (C-302/18), the European Court of Justice delivered a landmark judgement on the interpretation of the concept of “resources”, in the context of the third-country nationals’ right to long-term resident status.

Case in the main proceedings

A third-country national, has applied for long-term resident status. providing inter alia, evidences that his brother has stable, regular and sufficient means of subsistence. In addition, the applicant provided a document signed by his brother, stating that the former has for himself and for his dependent family members, stable, regular and sufficient means of subsistence.

The Belgian Immigration Office has rejected the application, on the ground that the applicant did not have his own resources.

Questions refereed to the ECJ for preliminary ruling

The referring court seeks to clarify the concept of “resources”, in the sense of Article 5(1)(a) Directive 2003/109:

a) whether only “own resources” must be considered, or the concept also covers resources made available to the applicant by a third party

b) whether merely a commitment of cost bearing, is sufficient to prove stable, regular and sufficient resources.

The ECJ ruling

1. Concept of “resources” in the context of it origin (in the sense of Article 5(1)(a) Directive 2003/109)

The said article does not contain any reference to national law, and as a consequence, it must be given an autonomous interpretation, considering the provision’: a) wording b) purpose c) context.

a) Wording -on its own does not make it possible to interpret the concept (is given different translations by different Member States).

b) Purpose -i) the principal objective of Directive 2003/109, is the integration of third-country nationals ii) the concept of integration is mainly determined by a period of five year lawful and continuous residence. It can be thus alleged that the origin of resources, does not appear to be decisive.

c) Context- -having stable, regular and sufficient resources, represents one of the substantive conditions for obtaining the status of long-term resident. However, prima facie, the origin of resources is not relevant.

Having regard to the above considerations, “Article 5(1)(a) of Directive 2003/109 does not, in principle, allow additional conditions to be laid down relating to the origin of the resources referred to in that provision”.

2. Concept of sufficient, stable and regular resources in the context of it origin (in the sense of Article 5(1)(a) Directive 2003/109)

a) Sufficient resources -by analogy to the interpretation given to Article 7(1)(b) Directive 2004/38, the applicant may rely on resources from a third party who is a member of his family.

b) Stable and regular resources -by analogy to Article 7(1)(c) Directive 2003/86, interpreted by the ECJ case law, “their sustainability and sufficiency, in view of the individual situation of the person concerned”, is decisive, and not the origin.

In the light of the above considerations, the origin of resources is not a decisive criterion for the Member State concerned, for the purpose of ascertaining whether they are stable, regular and sufficient.

However, “the legally binding nature of a commitment of cost bearing by a third party or a member of the applicant’s family, may be an important factor”.

AuthorTanel Feldman, Immigration Law AssociatesIn X (C-302/18), the European Court of Justice delivered a landmark judgement on the interpretation of the concept of “resources”, in the context of the third-country nationals’ right to long-term resident status.

Related Posts

Labour exploitation in the UK’s cleaning sector

Labour exploitation in the UK’s cleaning sector

Over the past months, Focus on Labour Exploitation (FLEX), the Latin American Women’s Rights Service (LAWRS) and the East European Resource Centre (EERC) have been busy running a project to help prevent labour exploitation in the UK’s cleaning...

Demands of easier and faster track to permanent work status in Canada

Demands of easier and faster track to permanent work status in Canada

Quebec immigrant advocacy groups call for more pathways to permanent Canadian residence. Many of those who attended the demonstration are temporary foreign workers, asylum seekers and international students who all want permanent status in Canada but feel there is too...

Changes to immigration policies and processes in New Zealand

Changes to immigration policies and processes in New Zealand

There have been a number of changes announced by Immigration New Zealand around the new employer accreditation and the accredited employer work visa (AEWV). At this point in time, businesses must: - Be a genuine operating business and hold a New Zealand Business...

Acute labour shortages affect food sector in UK

Acute labour shortages affect food sector in UK

MPs have warned that ministers' failure to address labor shortages caused by Brexit and the Covid epidemic could "permanently" reduce the UK's food sector, resulting in price increases. The Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee stated shortages were...

Immigration options for Russian nationals

Immigration options for Russian nationals

A sponsoring entity in the host country is likely required for many of the arrangements. But there are Relocation Options for Russian Nationals Such options include temporary measures such as visa-free entry or the ability to enter as a tourist initially before...

Afghanistan has been designated for Temporary Protected Status

Afghanistan has been designated for Temporary Protected Status

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced today that Afghanistan has been granted Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for 18 months. Only people who are already living in the United States on March 15, 2022, will be eligible for TPS. “This TPS designation will...