Italy Checklist: Sponsoring Highly Skilled Migrant Visas
Grab a copy of a guide to international employee relocation
View E-book
Global talent is on the move more than ever before. Yet for organizations, handling employee relocation is no small feat. It’s not just about getting someone from Point A to Point B—it’s about making sure your talented team members land smoothly and are ready to thrive in their new roles. As businesses scale internationally, choosing the right global mobility solution has never been more important. So, which is the better way to go: a “lump sum” approach, or a fully managed relocation program? Let’s unpack the details so you can make an informed decision that powers your people—and your business—forward.
First things first: what exactly are these two relocation strategies? A lump sum approach means giving the relocating employee a fixed amount of money to cover moving costs. This gives them flexibility to manage their own transition, from securing movers to arranging temporary housing. In contrast, a managed relocation program takes a hands-on approach—it’s a comprehensive service, usually provided by a third party, that handles the logistics, paperwork, and support for the employee every step of the way.
Nowadays, with the increased demand for cross-border assignments—45% of HR leaders expect international assignments to grow in the next two years, according to Deloitte’s Global Mobility Survey—companies are under pressure to make mobility smoother, more transparent, and cost-effective. The right choice could spell the difference between successful integration and a stressful, costly misstep.
The numbers don’t lie: global mobility is evolving fast. The Worldwide ERC, a mobility industry authority, reports that companies spend an average of $90,000 USD relocating a single employee internationally. Every dollar counts—so companies are searching for mobility solutions that combine efficiency with a human touch. In Gartner’s 2023 survey, 61% of organizations said the employee experience during relocation directly impacts assignment success and retention. That’s not just theory; it’s dollars and sense at work.
Lump sum relocations appeal to organizations for their predictability and simplicity—think of it as a “one and done” approach. In fact, a 2022 AIRINC study found that almost 70% of multinational companies offer lump sum packages as part of their overall mobility strategy. But, is this a case of convenience winning out over long-term success?
Lump sum has its advantages—it simplifies budgeting, cuts down on internal administration, and offers employees the freedom to devise their own moving plan. It sounds good, but there’s a flip side. Without expert guidance, employees might overspend in some areas and cut corners in others, risking compliance, well-being, and assignment success.
On the other hand, managed relocation programs, especially those powered by global mobility solutions like xpath.global, offer peace of mind. Employees receive end-to-end support—visa processing, housing, logistics, local orientation, and more—designed to minimize disruption and maximize productivity. Organizations can tap into a centralized dashboard for real-time tracking, ensuring everyone stays on the same page and in compliance with local regulations. However, this comes with a slightly higher administrative lift and, sometimes, cost.
Let’s bring this down from the clouds. A leading tech company based in Berlin adopted a lump sum policy to speed up decision-making and give autonomy to its employees. At first, it seemed streamlined. However, within months, HR received reports of delayed arrivals, missing documentation, and homesick employees who struggled with the cultural transition. By contrast, when the same company piloted a managed relocation service through xpath.global, the results were starkly different: onboarding was 40% faster, and post-move retention improved by 23%—all thanks to around-the-clock support and seamless coordination.
The takeaway? While lump sums may offer up-front simplicity, managed solutions can drive better long-term outcomes for both the business and the relocating talent.
There’s one more layer to this: compliance. Laws change by the country, sometimes by the city. Employees managing their own moves might miss critical legal steps, exposing the company to risk. Managed relocation services, particularly modern platforms like xpath.global, proactively ensure compliance every step of the journey. Plus, by alleviating the emotional burden of relocation, managed programs can help employees find their groove sooner, making them productive from day one.
It boils down to your business priorities. If cost and simplicity are key drivers, lump sums may look appealing—just be aware of the hidden risks and long-term retention factors. If you’re looking for assignment success, robust compliance, and enhanced employee experience, a managed relocation program—especially one leveraging future-ready tech like xpath.global—could be your golden ticket.
Still, remember that hybrid models exist too. Some organizations blend both approaches, offering core managed services with a lump sum add-on for flexibility.
Q: What is the key difference between lump sum and managed relocation programs?
A: Lump sum provides relocating employees with a fixed money amount for them to handle all arrangements, while managed relocation offers end-to-end services and support, handled by experts or relocation partners like xpath.global.
Q: Which approach offers more flexibility for employees?
A: Lump sum programs give employees more freedom to plan the move, but often at the expense of support and compliance oversight.
Q: Are managed relocation programs more expensive than lump sum?
A: Managed services may cost more up front but can save on hidden costs (delays, turnover, compliance fines) and drive higher employee satisfaction and retention.
Q: Can companies combine both approaches?
A: Absolutely! Hybrid models are on the rise, giving companies ways to tailor the mobility experience for different roles and employee needs.
Q: How does xpath.global fit in?
A: xpath.global is a global mobility platform that streamlines managed relocations, delivering expertise, compliance, and support while giving both employees and businesses full visibility and control over every step of the journey.
Ready to transform your mobility program? Explore xpath.global’s solutions.
Previous article
Italy Checklist: Sponsoring Highly Skilled Migrant Visas
Grab a copy of a guide to international employee relocation
View E-book